John Barilaro vs Google: How FriendlyJordies' YouTube Videos Triggered a Major Australian Defamation Case

By zen , 16 November 2026
John Barilaro's defamation battle against FriendlyJordies

Former New South Wales Deputy Premier John Barilaro became involved in one of Australia's most closely watched defamation disputes after taking legal action against YouTube comedian Jordan Shanks, better known as FriendlyJordies, and Google over videos published on the platform.

The controversy began with two satirical videos released in 2020, titled bruz and Secret Dictatorship. Barilaro argued that the videos portrayed him as corrupt, included racist references to his Italian heritage, and damaged his reputation.

The legal battle produced two separate outcomes. Shanks settled with Barilaro in November 2021, apologising and agreeing to edit the videos. Google, however, continued defending the separate lawsuit until the Federal Court ruled against the technology company in June 2022, ordering it to pay AUD $715,000 in damages.

How Did the John Barilaro and FriendlyJordies Controversy Begin?

Jordan Shanks built his online reputation through political satire and commentary on Australian politics. His YouTube channel, FriendlyJordies, became known for aggressively criticizing politicians, government decisions, and political institutions.

In September 2020, Shanks published a video titled bruz, targeting Barilaro, who was then serving as Deputy Premier of New South Wales and leader of the NSW Nationals.

The video accused Barilaro of corruption and questioned his political conduct. A second video, Secret Dictatorship, published the following month, made further allegations concerning his political dealings.

Barilaro argued that the videos went beyond legitimate political criticism. He claimed they falsely portrayed him as a corrupt politician and repeatedly used derogatory language referring to his Italian background.

He subsequently commenced defamation proceedings against Shanks and Google, the company that owned YouTube.

Why Did John Barilaro Sue Jordan Shanks?

Barilaro's legal complaint focused on the meaning and presentation of the videos rather than simply their criticism of his political decisions.

He argued that the material communicated defamatory allegations, including that he was a corrupt conman who had engaged in dishonest political conduct.

He also objected to racial insults and repeated personal attacks that he believed had turned political commentary into harassment.

Another important issue was the public response to the videos. Barilaro told the Federal Court that he experienced threatening confrontations with members of the public who had watched Shanks' content.

He also described the emotional consequences of the campaign, including serious psychological distress and thoughts of self-harm.

His evidence became an important part of the subsequent case against Google.

Jordan Shanks Apologises and Settles the Defamation Case

On November 5, 2021, Barilaro's defamation action against Shanks was settled before a full trial.

As part of the agreement, Shanks accepted that some of his videos had been offensive and apologised for the hurt caused to Barilaro.

The settlement also required him to edit two videos to remove the disputed offensive material and stop selling merchandise featuring Barilaro after his retirement from politics.

Shanks did not pay defamation damages to Barilaro. However, he agreed to pay approximately AUD $100,000 in legal costs associated with the proceedings.

Importantly, the settlement did not require the complete removal of the videos from YouTube.

Barilaro accepted the apology and described the settlement as a positive outcome. However, his separate case against Google continued.

Why Did John Barilaro Take Google to Court?

Barilaro's case against Google focused on the company's responsibility for content published through YouTube.

He argued that Google had been notified about the allegedly defamatory material but failed to remove the videos or adequately address the complaints.

The legal question was whether Google could be held responsible as a publisher after becoming aware of the material and allowing it to remain available on its platform.

Google initially defended the proceedings, but it progressively abandoned its defence arguments before the final judgment.

The company eventually conceded that the videos had caused significant harm to Barilaro.

The case therefore became an important test of the responsibility digital platforms may have when users publish defamatory material and the platform receives complaints about it.

Federal Court Orders Google to Pay AUD $715,000

On June 6, 2022, Federal Court Justice Steven Rares delivered judgment in Barilaro v Google LLC [2022] FCA 650.

The court ordered Google to pay Barilaro AUD $715,000, comprising AUD $675,000 in damages and AUD $40,000 in prejudgment interest.

The judge found that Google had become liable as a publisher after being notified about the defamatory material and failing to remove it.

Justice Rares also criticized the company's handling of the complaints and its conduct during the proceedings.

The judgment identified several particularly serious aspects of the material:

  • Defamation: The videos conveyed defamatory imputations about Barilaro's character and political conduct.
  • Racial abuse: The content included repeated derogatory references to his Italian heritage.
  • Cyberbullying: The campaign extended beyond ordinary political criticism into personal intimidation and harassment.
  • Failure to respond adequately: Google failed to apply its own policies effectively after receiving complaints.
  • Aggravated harm: The company's conduct during the proceedings increased the damage suffered by Barilaro.

The judge concluded that the campaign had significantly traumatized Barilaro and contributed to his premature departure from public office.

Judge Raises Concerns About Contempt of Court

Another significant aspect of the judgment concerned videos published by Shanks during the legal proceedings.

Some of the material targeted Barilaro's lawyers and questioned their professional integrity. Justice Rares considered the publications particularly serious because they appeared calculated to intimidate the legal team and discourage them from continuing to represent Barilaro.

The judge referred the conduct of Google and Shanks to the Federal Court's Principal Registrar to consider whether contempt proceedings should be initiated.

This was a referral for consideration, not a finding that either party had already been convicted of contempt.

The issue highlighted the importance of protecting access to justice and ensuring that legal representatives can perform their duties without improper intimidation.

Did FriendlyJordies Lose the Right to Criticize Politicians?

The case generated considerable debate about freedom of expression and the boundaries of political satire in Australia.

Supporters of Shanks argued that political commentators should be able to scrutinize public officials aggressively, particularly when discussing allegations of corruption and government accountability.

However, the Federal Court made an important distinction between legitimate political criticism and defamatory personal attacks.

Justice Rares acknowledged that politicians must tolerate robust criticism and that public debate can be uncomfortable, provocative, and even harsh.

Nevertheless, the right to criticize political figures does not provide unlimited protection for racist abuse, harassment, or allegations without an adequate factual basis.

The judgment did not establish that FriendlyJordies could no longer criticize Barilaro or other politicians. Instead, it addressed the specific defamatory material and Google's responsibility for continuing to publish it after receiving notice.

What Happened to John Barilaro After the Case?

Barilaro had already resigned from his position as Deputy Premier in October 2021, following a difficult period involving political controversy and the online campaign.

He subsequently moved away from frontline politics and pursued activities outside his previous government role.

The court judgment provided a degree of legal vindication, although Barilaro acknowledged that removing the original videos could not completely eliminate their circulation across the internet.

He also emphasized that his original objective had been to obtain an apology and have the offensive material removed, rather than simply receive financial compensation.

Why the Google Defamation Case Matters Today

The Barilaro case remains significant because it illustrates that online platforms may face legal consequences for content they continue to publish after receiving notice of defamatory material.

It also demonstrates the distinction between the responsibility of an original content creator and that of a platform distributing the material.

Shanks settled his case with Barilaro through an apology, video edits, and payment of legal costs. Google faced a separate judgment because of its conduct as a publisher on YouTube.

For digital platforms, the case highlighted the importance of responding to complaints involving defamation, harassment, and hate speech rather than relying solely on their general content policies.

For political commentators, it reinforced the principle that strong criticism remains protected, but personal attacks and defamatory allegations can carry legal consequences.

Conclusion

John Barilaro's legal battle against FriendlyJordies and Google became one of Australia's most prominent disputes involving online defamation and political satire.

Jordan Shanks settled the case against him in November 2021, apologising to Barilaro, agreeing to edit two videos, and paying approximately AUD $100,000 in legal costs without paying defamation damages.

Google's separate case ended in June 2022 when the Federal Court ordered the company to pay AUD $715,000 in damages and interest for publishing defamatory material on YouTube after receiving notice of its content.

The judgment did not eliminate the right to criticize politicians. Rather, it established an important distinction between legitimate public scrutiny and conduct involving defamation, racial abuse, and cyberbullying.

Ultimately, the case became a significant reference point in Australia's ongoing debate over freedom of expression, online accountability, and the legal responsibilities of social media platforms.