The Curious Case of the Dog in Rembrandt's The Night Watch: A 400-Year-Old Mystery Solved

By zen , 20 November 2026
A hidden clue in Rembrandt's The Night Watch

A small barking dog hidden among the figures in Rembrandt van Rijn's famous painting The Night Watch has revealed an unexpected connection to another Dutch artist. Art historians at Amsterdam's Rijksmuseum discovered that the animal was based on an earlier drawing by Adriaen van de Venne, created more than two decades before Rembrandt completed his 1642 masterpiece.

The discovery, announced in September 2025, emerged from Operation Night Watch, an extensive research and restoration project examining the painting using advanced imaging technology and historical investigation. It provides new insight into Rembrandt's creative process and the artistic influences behind one of the most celebrated paintings of the Dutch Golden Age.

The Hidden Dog in Rembrandt's The Night Watch

At first glance, The Night Watch appears to be a monumental depiction of an Amsterdam civic guard company preparing to march. The painting features dozens of figures, including Captain Frans Banninck Cocq, Lieutenant Willem van Ruytenburch, soldiers, musicians, and other members of the militia.

Among the activity in the lower-right section of the composition is a small dog positioned near a drummer. Partially obscured by the surrounding figures and shadows, the animal is easy to overlook when viewing the painting.

The dog appears to be barking in response to the drummer's instrument. Its open mouth, alert posture, and upward-looking head introduce another element of movement and sound into the crowded military scene.

According to Rijksmuseum curator Anne Lenders, the dog helps communicate the atmosphere of the moment. The drummer creates noise, the animal reacts, and the painting becomes more dynamic rather than remaining a conventional group portrait.

How Art Historians Discovered the Dog's Original Inspiration

The breakthrough came when Anne Lenders visited an exhibition at the Zeeuws Museum in Middelburg, Netherlands. During her visit, she encountered a historical drawing by Adriaen van de Venne that immediately reminded her of the dog in Rembrandt's painting.

The resemblance was unusually strong. Both dogs had nearly identical head positions, upward gazes, slightly open mouths, and similar collars. Their bodies also followed a comparable diagonal arrangement, with their upper sections positioned close to the ground.

Lenders subsequently compared the historical drawing with the dog in The Night Watch. Further investigation confirmed that the similarities extended beyond a general resemblance and included distinctive anatomical and compositional details.

The Rijksmuseum announced the discovery on September 17, 2025, identifying Van de Venne's drawing as the likely visual source for Rembrandt's depiction.

Who Was Adriaen van de Venne?

Adriaen van de Venne (1590–1662) was a Dutch Golden Age artist, poet, and publisher known for his paintings, illustrations, and literary collaborations.

The drawing identified by Lenders dates to 1619. It was created as a design for the engraved title page of Self-stryt, dat is, Krachtighe beweginghe van Vlees ende Gheest, a religious and moral book by Dutch writer Jacob Cats, first published in 1620.

The illustration depicts the biblical story of Joseph being tempted by Potiphar's wife. A dog appears within the composition, displaying a remarkably similar head position and body arrangement to the animal later painted by Rembrandt.

Although Van de Venne is less internationally recognized than Rembrandt, the discovery highlights his contribution to the visual culture of seventeenth-century Dutch art.

The Striking Similarities Between the Two Dogs

The Rijksmuseum's investigation identified several specific similarities between the two representations.

  • Head position: Both dogs turn their heads upward at almost identical angles.
  • Facial features: Their mouths are slightly open, while a dark line marks the position of the right eye.
  • Head structure: The skullcap is divided into two recognizable sections in both depictions.
  • Collars: The collars display closely corresponding designs.
  • Body posture: Both animals are positioned diagonally, with their upper bodies close to the ground.

There are also important differences. Van de Venne's dog lies with its front legs and chest against the ground, while Rembrandt's final version stands on all four legs. Rembrandt also modified the animal's facial expression, making its mouth wider and adding a visible tongue to suggest barking.

These changes demonstrate that Rembrandt did not simply reproduce the earlier illustration. He adapted its visual elements to fit the movement and atmosphere of his own composition.

Scientific Imaging Revealed an Earlier Version of the Dog

One of the most significant aspects of the discovery came from scientific examination conducted during Operation Night Watch.

Researchers used macro X-ray fluorescence (MA-XRF) analysis to investigate the underlying layers of the painting. This technology allowed specialists to examine the distribution of chemical elements and identify details beneath the visible paint surface.

The analysis revealed that Rembrandt initially painted the dog's right front leg in a more bent position, with its chest closer to the ground. This preliminary composition was even more similar to Van de Venne's drawing than the finished version.

The finding strengthened the argument that the earlier illustration influenced Rembrandt's initial design before he modified the animal's posture.

Earlier research published by the Rijksmuseum in December 2021 had also explained why the dog appeared unusually pale and whitish. Investigators discovered that the effect was partly caused by a chalk-rich preparatory sketch layer becoming exposed through abrasion from previous conservation treatments.

Was Rembrandt Copying Another Artist?

The discovery raises an interesting question about originality and artistic borrowing during the seventeenth century.

Modern audiences might interpret the similarities as an example of copying. However, the use of existing drawings, prints, and visual references was a recognized part of artistic practice during Rembrandt's lifetime.

The Rijksmuseum describes this practice in terms of artistic emulation. Painters studied existing compositions and incorporated recognizable elements into their own work, often transforming them to create something new.

Rembrandt owned an extensive collection of prints and drawings by other artists. Researchers have not established whether Van de Venne's original drawing was personally among his possessions, so the exact way Rembrandt encountered the image remains uncertain.

Nevertheless, additional similarities between Van de Venne's illustration and Rembrandt's later depictions of the biblical story of Joseph provide further evidence that he was familiar with the subject matter.

Why the Dog Matters to The Night Watch

The discovery is significant because it reveals how Rembrandt constructed the visual language of his masterpiece.

Rather than treating every figure and animal as an entirely independent invention, he drew upon existing visual references and transformed them to support the overall composition.

The dog also serves a specific artistic purpose. Its reaction to the drummer reinforces the suggestion of sound and activity, helping the viewer imagine the scene as a moment unfolding rather than a collection of stationary figures.

Although relatively small compared with the monumental human figures, the animal contributes to the painting's sense of movement and realism.

Operation Night Watch Continues to Reveal New Details

Operation Night Watch began in 2019 and represents the Rijksmuseum's most comprehensive scientific and artistic investigation of Rembrandt's famous painting.

The project brings together art historians, conservators, scientists, and technical specialists to examine the canvas, its pigments, preparatory sketches, and physical condition.

Previous research identified previously hidden preparatory sketches, investigated changes in the painting's original appearance, and examined the materials Rembrandt used to construct the composition.

The dog discovery demonstrates the value of combining traditional art history with modern scientific methods. Even a painting that has been studied for centuries can reveal new information when researchers examine its details from a different perspective.

In September 2025, the Rijksmuseum also published a scholarly study by Anne Lenders in the Rijksmuseum Bulletin, formally presenting the evidence connecting Rembrandt's dog to Van de Venne's 1619 drawing.

A Small Dog That Changed How We Understand a Masterpiece

The mystery surrounding the dog in The Night Watch offers a fascinating example of how historical artworks continue to reveal unexpected stories. What initially appeared to be a minor detail in Rembrandt's crowded composition turned out to have a connection to an earlier illustration by another Dutch artist.

The finding does not diminish Rembrandt's achievement. Instead, it provides a clearer understanding of how he studied, adapted, and transformed existing artistic ideas into a distinctive masterpiece.

Nearly four centuries after its creation, The Night Watch continues to offer new discoveries, proving that even its smallest characters can have remarkable histories.